Legal Thrillers

David Ellis
§ Eye of the Beholder
§ In the Company of Liars
§ Line of Vision
Linda Fairstein
§ Entombed
Gini Hartzmark
§ Dead Certain
§ Final Option
§ Principal Defense
§ Rough Trade


In the Company of Liars, David Ellis, Putnam, $24.95.

I already know this is one of my favorite reads of the year - it's one of the more intelligently and cleverly structured novels I've ever read. I had met David Ellis when he came to sign books at Aunt Agatha's last spring, and he told me that his next book was told completely backwards - an idea I thought might be too high concept to be workable. I shouldn't have underestimated him; Ellis is one of the best - if not the best - legal thriller writer working at the moment. He beats the pants off John Grisham, and his consistency - so far four wonderful novels and counting - pulls him ahead of Scott Turow as well. Combining the thriller skills of Grisham (while adding a great deal more imagination) and the characterization gifts of Turow, these books are a combination that can hardly be beat, and In the Company of Liars is completely remarkable.

Starting at the end of the story and working backwards would seem to be almost anti-suspenseful, but in fact, it's exactly the opposite. As you flip through each chapter and the picture of what's going on becomes clearer, the desire to rush ahead and find more clarity still becomes stronger and stronger. These books aren't strictly legal thrillers but all have a strong legal background; to call them modern morality tales might be closer to the truth. This story centers around a well known true crime writer, Allison Pagone, and her apparent suicide at the beginning - or end? - of the book. As you read forward, the mix includes a foreign terrorist, a pair of special agents from the FBI, and a murder that Allison may or may not have committed, though the evidence seems (emphasis on seems) pretty conclusive. As you read, Allison's life and choices as well as her family situation become clearer and clearer, and there are plenty of surprises left by the end of the novel. I wonder if this book might be so completely enjoyable that it's dismissed as a "mere" narrative tour de force - but if you read it carefully, it's really much more than that. Ellis' exploration of the characters and the reasons they behave the way they do are the explorations of a pure novelist. He's just a pure novelist who happens to tell a cracking good story. (Robin)

David Ellis Chronology:
Line of Vision (Edgar Winner, Best First Novel)
Life Sentence
Jury of One

To browse more reviews, use the navigation links at the top of the page.